Michael Luther timing

Du hast Fragen zu Regeln oder Karten? Stell sie hier!
Post Reply
User avatar
Johannes
Vorsintflutlicher
Vorsintflutlicher
Posts: 3405
Joined: 18 Nov 2002, 11:17
Location: Speyer
VEKN Nr.:
Contact:

Michael Luther timing

Post by Johannes »

Für die Teilnehmer unseres letzten "Wednesday Night Jyhad" sicherlich interessant. Kleine Vorschau : Ich hatte mal wieder Unrecht :D Aber es wäre doch sooo schön gewesen .... achso der "Correct. ..." post ist von LSJ aber das hättet Ihr Euch ja auch denken können.

>>One question came up in our latest V:TES night. I was controlling Michael
>>Luther and during a referendums we had the following situation (a bit
>>complicated):
>>I had 7 votes in favor, they had 8 votes against (4 princes). One of them
>>had a Justicar and he said the Justicar abstains from the referendum. The
>>were waiting that I change 1 prince in my favor thus making it 9 to 6 and
>>then voting with the Justicar to make the referendum fail. I was argumenting
>>that Michael Luthers ability can be applied after all votes were cast to
>>change one of the vampires votes and that I can change an abstaining
>>vampires votes. They were trying to argument that I cannot change abstaining
>>vampires votes and they can wait "forever" with the justicar to cast votes
>>just until Michael Luther has been tapped.
>>
>>So the question is : can I pass the referendum (how and why?) or can I not
>>(why?) ?
>
>
> You cannot force them to vote.
> The ability can only be used *after* they have voted -not if they don't
> vote. (first post googling for "luther" in the NG)
> After you use your ability they have the right to cast votes.
>
> They can wait 'forever' inasmuch as they don't have to vote -at some
> point you can call for any more votes and then declare the referendum
> over BUT you cannot use your ability after the referendum is over and
> nor can you use it and then rush to end the referendum before they can
> vote.
>
> You can't pass this referendum unless you have some other form of vote
> push.

Correct.
If everyone reaches the "I won't do anything until someone else does"
point, then it's time to close the referendum.


V:TES online shop http://www.vtes.de
User avatar
Erol
Inconnu
Inconnu
Posts: 1564
Joined: 30 Mar 2003, 21:22
Location: Karlsruhe
VEKN Nr.:
Has thanked: 4 times
Been thanked: 13 times
Contact:

Post by Erol »

Da guckschte mal. Bin ich nicht ein guter Judge Assistant! :twisted:
Be as smart as you can, but remember that it is always better to be wise than to be smart. (Alan Alda)
Post Reply